Regular consumption of caffeinated coffee may help prevent
the return of colon cancer after treatment and improve the chances of a cure,
according to a new, large study from Dana-Farber Cancer Institute that reported this striking association for the first time.
The patients, all of them treated with surgery and
chemotherapy for stage III colon cancer, had the greatest benefit from
consuming four or more cups of coffee a day (about 460 milligrams of caffeine),
according to the study published in the Journal
of Clinical Oncology. These patients were 42 percent less likely to have
their cancer return than non-coffee drinkers, and were 34 percent less likely
to die from cancer or any other cause.
Two to three cups of coffee daily had a more modest benefit,
while little protection was associated with one cup or less, reported the
researchers, led by Charles S. Fuchs, MD, MPH, director of the Gastrointestinal Cancer Center at
author is Brendan J. Guercio, MD, also of Dana-Farber.
The study included nearly 1,000 patients who filled out
dietary pattern questionnaires early in the study, during chemotherapy and
again about a year later. This "prospective" design eliminated patients' need
to recall their coffee-drinking habits years later – a source of potential bias
in many observational studies.
"We found that coffee drinkers had a lower risk of the cancer
coming back and a significantly greater survival and chance of a cure," Fuchs
said. Most recurrences happen within five years of treatment and are uncommon
after that, he noted. In patients with stage III disease, the cancer has been
found in the lymph nodes near the original tumor but there are no signs of
further metastasis. Fuchs said these patients have about a 35 percent chance of
As encouraging as the results appear to be, Fuchs is hesitant
to make recommendations to patients until the results are confirmed in other
studies. "If you are a coffee drinker and are being treated for colon cancer,
don't stop," he said. "But if you're not a coffee drinker and wondering whether
to start, you should first discuss it with your physician."
Fuchs said the study is the first to study an association
between caffeinated coffee and risk of colon cancer recurrence. It adds to a
number of recent studies suggesting that coffee may have protective effects
against the development of several kinds of cancer, including reduced risks of
postmenopausal breast cancer, melanoma, liver cancer, advanced prostate cancer.
Fuchs said the research focused on coffee and other dietary
factors because coffee drinking – in addition to possibly being protective
against some cancers – had been shown to reduce the risk of type 2 diabetes.
Risk factors for diabetes – obesity, a sedentary life style, a Western diet
high in calories and sugar, and high levels of insulin – are also implicated in
In analyzing the results of the new study, Fuchs and his
colleagues discovered that the lowered risk of cancer recurrence and deaths was
entirely due to caffeine and not other components of coffee. He said it's not
clear why caffeine has this effect and the question needs further study. One
hypothesis is that caffeine consumption increases the body's sensitivity to
insulin so less of it is needed, which in turn may help reduce inflammation – a
risk factor for diabetes and cancer, Fuchs said.
Other than drinking coffee, Fuchs said, people can take other
measures to reduce cancer risks – avoiding obesity, exercising regularly,
adopting a healthier diet, and eating nuts, which also reduce the risk of
Jeffrey Meyerhardt, MD, MPH, clinical director of the
Gastrointestinal Cancer Centerat Dana-Farber, is co-senior author of the
The research was supported by National Institutes of Health
U10CA180821 and U10CA180882 to the Alliance for Clinical Trials in Oncology,
CA31946 and CA33601 to the legacy CALGB, and CA180820 to the ECOG-ACRIN. Additional support was provided under CA32291, CA77651, CA45808,
CA45808, CA60138, CA32291, CA32291, and from Pharmacia & Upjohn
Company, now Pfizer Oncology. Fuchs and Meyerhardt are supported in part by
grants from the National Cancer Institute (R01 CA118553, R01 CA149222, R01
CA169141, and P50 CA127003).